Fear is a
factor that cripples mind; fear is a factor that shows in eyes; fear is a
factor that makes you frantic; fear is a factor that makes you mad.
Mr. Naseeruddin
Shah has been under fear for whatever of his reasons but despite the fear he
still enjoys his life in his rarefied home area, despite the fear he still
enjoys a spick and span loo in his home and despite the fear he and his family
is still safe.
Now during
the cold winters of early 1990 the war cries of hatred made the milieu of valley
in Kashmir vitriolic.
Some of the
slogans used in the valley during that time are as follows:
“Ralive, Tsaliv ya
Galive” (either
convert to Islam, leave the land, or die)
“Kashir banawon Pakistan,
Bataw varaie, Batneiw saan”
(We will
turn Kashmir into Pakistan alongwith Kashmiri Pandit women, but without their
men folk)
"Dil mein rakho Allah ka
khauf; Hath mein rakho Kalashnikov"
(With fear
of Allah ruling your hearts, wield a Kalashnikov)
“Yahan kya chalega,
Nizam-e- Mustafa”
(We want to
be ruled under Shari’ah)
And you know
what such slogans did? They instilled fear in the hearts of mothers to such an extent that they were
ready to kill their daughters before killing self; the families were ready to
vacate their ancestral homes and take refuge in camps where there were no
proper sanitation facilities available. (If anyone who has ever had the opportunity
to defecate in open can understand the shame that it imbues in you and
especially in those who had used toilets in their houses before.)
People are
still bound to be stuffed in a small space with at least their three
generations whereas they were owners of spacious accommodations just two and
half decade ago.
I mean this
is called fear.
Then he said
that he was not afraid but he was angry because of the general situation in the
country that is happening on the name of religion.
I mean just
for once think about the anger of those whose land were dismembered in the name
of religion. Think about anger of those, whose Hinglaj Bhawani is restricted to only books of Durga Chalisa…in general condition they can never go to Hinglaj temple in this birth. Think
about anger of those whose sacred places were destroyed in the name of showing one-upmanship
on the face of earth and they are reduced to a situation that in their own land
they are running from pillar to post to build a temple for their revered God.
I mean come
on… this was not expected from Mr. Naseeruddin Shah whom the nation never
considered as only a Muslim when it watched him perform in Sparsh,Mirch Masala,Wednesday,Masoom
or Paar for that matter. Since he was associated with sensible cinema, some
sensible reactions from him was expected not the mera wala fear or mera wala
anger.
When anyone of
a stature, that Mr. Naseeruddin Shah enjoys, makes a comment on the situation
of the country the constraint should be exercised. Because when anything
undesirable happens due to the comments, it is the common men who suffer and need
succor from each other in distressful situations. The celebrities remain in
their secured citadels. And when some prominent personality of the society makes
such statements, it is perceived that the milieu must be really bad otherwise why
someone of his stature would be talking about it on the T.V.
We have a
driver working in our company. One day he told that he needs some holidays to
build his house. I was a bit startled to know that a driver was making his
house whereas a private naukri –wala-
admi spends his whole life in rented accommodations. When I enquired
further on how he marshaled financial resources to make a home he told that he
was granted Rs. 2,20,000 from some govt. scheme that doles out money to build
houses to people belonging to poor class. I was startled to know that the govt.
scheme didn’t differentiate in a Hindu and Muslim and even if our Driver is a
Muslim, he got the benefit of the scheme on the yardsticks of being the
countryman. Later, the driver told that his family members were immensely benefited
from some Mobile Health Vehicles (again run by Govt.) that go to small villages
and help complete whatever of tests required for a patient or could be done for
a patient in a mobile health vehicle.
I think that
these positive things that happen on ground level should be the epicenter of talks
while talking about the image of the country.
On the ground
level the Hindu and Muslim community needs each other more frequently than
those who live in their own secured world.
In 2016
there was some communal tension in my city but not of the flagrant nature but
while we were at our office, words spread that shops were being closed down and
general transportation was stopped. We were advised to leave the office as soon
as possible. I had my driver (who also happens to be a Muslim) not of company,
with me that day, and seeing the desolate roads he got panicked. I assured him
that first I would drop him in his house only then I would go to mine. We moved
towards his house but I was also anxious of anything untoward that could have
happened. I left him at his home and then I drove as fast as possible to my
house.
Anyways, the
roads were totally empty that day, so that also added to my speed. But during
that period I had experienced immense fear I mean when there is a riot no one recognizes
anyone. I just want to say that even if I am not a superman, I decided that
first I would drop my driver at his house and then I would go to mine. I didn't see that my driver was a Muslim, he was my driver only and a human being whose family was waiting for him. And the
same way my driver is ready for me whenever there is any emergency situation in
my life. I mean though we are Hindu and Muslim yet seldom have we had any fear
of each other.
Under our
company another entity works as our sub-contractor and the proprietor of that
company is Muslim. But workers working under him are Hindus also and he is ever
ready to help them out whenever there is an emergency situation in the lives of
his Hindu workers. And mind you the help that he provides in shape of money is
other than that he is legally bound to pay like: Salary, ESI, and PF.
With the two
examples, I just want to show that the two communities, generally, are not baying
for blood of each other on day to day basis and what is shown on TV might
sometimes be aloof from what the reality might be.And since the reach of T.V
is maximum, use of it should also have some responsibility. And the more
positive we talk; the more the negatives will wilt, on their own.
###
You raise very valid points. A grave injustice has been done to Kashmiri Pandits. It is also true that government schemes do not discriminate between Hindus and Muslims. I do not agree with what Naseruddin Shah says. But a sensitive government should assuage his fear. That would be the mature way to dealing with the problem. Simply talking does not mean government has to change its policies. Talk to people who do not agree with you. Dosent government deal with terrorists, political opponents and other people who speak or work against government's point of view.
ReplyDeleteThanks Abhijit and speaking your mind on the post.
Deletevery heavy post... thought provoking.
ReplyDeleteThanks Bhawana for visit and comment to the post.
DeleteVery well written post highlighting the fear feeling arising out of the disturbing socio-political situations and real life experiences in correlation to the recent controversial statement by the mentioned actor ๐ ๐ ๐
ReplyDeleteThanks Sachin for visiting the post and posting your comment.
Deleteyour post is simply great n thought provoking. i don't know how correct i am , still i would like to share my views -
ReplyDeleteEarlier religious suppression , taxes etc were common by the ruling kings .
This fear feeling (Religious violence in India) was aggravated during British rule as they wanted to divide and rule us.And still politicians are using that strategy and we are the suffers.
Earlier religious clashes was common generally among themselves - siya -sunni, catholics-protestants, hindu-buddists , shaiv- vaishnav (very less hindus know this fact that เคถैเคต-เคตैเคท्เคฃเคต) serious clashes were common during kumbh shahi snaan.
Yes...you are also right but still there are somethings that are unreasonably wrong.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your visit and comment Rekha Jee.